Cast Down Your Bucket Here
By Michael Kleen

An abreviated version of this article appeared in the
Daily Eastern News on March 20, 2007, and the
Rock River Times in their Aug. 6-12, 2008 issue

There are many answers to our current economic crisis, but only one that preserves the choice and freedom that Americans demand.  Government control of the economy, even in the form of “investment” in banks and other industries, is not, as we are being told, the only way out of this mess, especially since the collusion of government and financial interests is what got us here in the first place.

In a column written in 2007, I argued that the best economic model we have is a decentralized, locally oriented economy.  This type of economy keeps more money in the community where it is needed, creates higher paying jobs, allows for increased accountability by business owners, generates more tax revenue, and increases the variety of goods in which to buy.
    
You shouldn’t have to look forward to being a door greeter at Wal-Mart when you retire.  You could be passing your own business down to your sons and daughters, or looking forward to growing old inside the walls of the business that you helped to build.  I believe that it’s not too late to turn things around.

In 1895, famed educator and author Booker T. Washington cajoled members of his community to “cast down your bucket where you are” instead of seeking labor or employment somewhere else.  Likewise, I firmly believe that more can be accomplished for the benefit of our community by casting our talents and our dollars where we live by buying and producing locally, as well as abandoning the “there’s nothing I can do” attitude.
    
The real problem is not a lack of business or services, the problem is the complainers who, when it comes down to it, do nothing to prevent businesses from leaving and whose solution to the problems they see is to uproot and leave, or spend their dollars elsewhere, convinced that nothing can be done.
    
For a community to be successful all the members of that community need to act together to bring the kind of entertainment, businesses, and recreation they want to see, as well as support those facilities already in existence.
    
Supporting local businesses means using your dollars like votes in favor of the businesses you want to remain in town.  Every dollar you spend contributes to the revitalization of the community.  According to a December 2002 study by Civic Economics, spending $100 at a chain bookstore generated $13 in local economic activity, while spending the same amount at a locally owned bookstore generated $45 in local economic activity.  This is because local stores pay higher wages, spend more money in the community, and keep their profits in town.
    
If you wish to see a more viable and diverse local economy, cast your dollars at locally owned stores instead of national retailers.  According to a 2005 study of 1,749 counties conducted by the University of Missouri, an average of 4 small, 1 midsized, and 1 large retail store shuttered in each county within 5 years of the arrival of a Wal-Mart.  Furthermore, Wal-Mart reduced average earnings between .5 and .9 percent, which means less money spent in the community. According to the National Trust for Historic Preservation, 84 percent of Wal-Mart sales comes at the expense of local businesses.
    
Locally owned businesses positively affect city revenue.  According to a July 2002 report by Tischler & Associates, local retail stores annually generate an average of $326 in tax revenue per 1,000 square feet of store space, while national chain stores engender an annual deficit of $468, due to the tax dollars used to accommodate these national chains.  In the summer of 2003, Wal-Mart attempted to shake down the city of Chicago for $18 million for the ‘privilege’ of building a store there.  According to the Chicago Sun-Times, Mayor Daley was dumbfounded and responded by asking, “Am I buying the company?”
    
Imagine if a stranger came to your town and announced that he was going to close businesses, depress wages, and siphon money out of the community. To top it all off, he asked you to finance the operation!  This man would be run out of town as a lunatic. Yet national retail chains do just that in towns and cities all over America, while deluded city governments welcome them with open arms.
    
The situation is not hopeless.  Local businesses close for the simple fact that we are not spending our money to support them, and therefore those who refuse to put their money where their mouth is do not deserve to complain when they see the dozens of shuttered businesses in their town or city.  Study after study has shown that every dollar you spend does matter.  If you wish to see a viable economy, cast down your bucket where you are!

 This short opinion piece is by no means authoritative, but is simply meant to be an introduction to this issue.

Reproduction of material from any original Blackoakmedia.org pages
without written permission is strictly prohibited.
Copyright 2008 Black Oak Media